25 Christmas Gift Exchange Ideas for Big Families

Large families can make holiday gift-giving challenging and expensive. Here are 25 Christmas gift exchange ideas for big families that can help manage costs, add excitement, and create memorable experiences for everyone involved.

Popular Gift Exchange Formats for Large Families

Secret Santa

Secret Santa is a classic gift exchange format that works well for big families. Here’s how it typically works:

1. Put all family members’ names in a hat or use an online tool to randomly assign gift recipients.
2. Set a budget limit for gifts, usually between $20-$50.
3. Keep the gift recipient’s identity secret until the exchange.
4. On the day of the exchange, everyone opens their gift and tries to guess who their Secret Santa was.

This method ensures everyone gets one thoughtful gift without the need to buy for every family member.

White Elephant / Yankee Swap

White Elephant, also known as Yankee Swap, adds an element of fun and strategy to gift exchanges:

1. Each person brings one wrapped gift within an agreed budget.
2. Draw numbers to determine the order of choosing gifts.
3. The first person selects and unwraps a gift.
4. Subsequent players can either steal an opened gift or choose a new wrapped one.
5. If a gift is stolen, that person can then steal from someone else or open a new gift.
6. Set a limit on how many times a gift can be stolen (usually 3 times).

This game creates excitement and laughter as family members compete for the most desirable gifts.

Ornament Exchange

An ornament exchange is a simple and festive option:

1. Ask each family member to bring a wrapped Christmas tree ornament.
2. Set a reasonable price limit, like $10-$15.
3. Use a gift exchange method like drawing names or playing White Elephant.
4. Everyone goes home with a new ornament to add to their tree.

This idea is budget-friendly and helps family members build their ornament collections over the years.

Creative Gift Exchange Themes

DIY Gifts Only

Encourage creativity and personal touch with a DIY-only gift exchange:

1. Set rules that all gifts must be handmade or personally customized.
2. Provide a list of DIY gift ideas for inspiration.
3. Set a materials budget limit to keep things fair.
4. Use any gift exchange format like Secret Santa or White Elephant.

DIY gifts can include homemade food items, crafts, personalized photo gifts, or handmade decorations.

Book Exchange

For families who love to read, a book exchange can be a great option:

1. Each person brings a wrapped book they enjoyed or think someone else would like.
2. Set a price limit or specify new vs. used books.
3. Use a White Elephant style exchange or draw names.
4. Include a note explaining why you chose the book to make it more personal.

This exchange can introduce family members to new authors or genres they might not have tried otherwise.

Experience Gifts

Instead of physical items, focus on gifting experiences:

1. Set a budget for experience gifts (e.g., $50-$100).
2. Ideas can include concert tickets, museum passes, cooking classes, or spa treatments.
3. Use a Secret Santa format to assign gift recipients.
4. The gift-giver can either purchase a specific experience or give a gift card allowing the recipient to choose.

Experience gifts create lasting memories and can be especially meaningful for family members who already have plenty of material possessions.

Gift Exchange Games and Activities

Dice Gift Exchange Game

Add an element of chance to your gift exchange with a dice game:

1. Everyone brings a wrapped gift within the agreed budget.
2. Sit in a circle with the gifts in the center.
3. Take turns rolling a pair of dice.
4. Assign actions to different dice rolls (e.g., pick a gift, swap gifts, pass all gifts left).
5. Continue until everyone has had several turns or a set time limit is reached.

This game keeps everyone engaged and adds unpredictability to the gift-giving process.

Christmas Scavenger Hunt

Turn gift-giving into an adventure with a scavenger hunt:

1. Assign each family member a gift recipient.
2. Hide the gifts around the house or yard.
3. Create clues leading to each gift’s location.
4. Give each person their first clue and let the hunt begin.
5. Set a time limit to add excitement.

This activity adds physical activity and problem-solving to the gift exchange, making it more memorable.

Gift Unwrapping Challenge

Make opening gifts a competition:

1. Wrap gifts in multiple layers of wrapping paper, boxes, or other materials.
2. Divide family members into teams.
3. Set a timer and see which team can unwrap their gift first using only one hand or while wearing oven mitts.
4. The winning team gets to choose their gift first from the pile.

This game adds laughter and friendly competition to the gift-opening process.

Budget-Friendly Gift Exchange Ideas

$10 Gift Challenge

Keep costs low while encouraging creativity:

1. Set a strict $10 limit for all gifts.
2. Challenge family members to find the most interesting or useful gift within this budget.
3. Use any gift exchange format like Secret Santa or White Elephant.
4. Award a small prize for the most creative $10 gift.

This challenge can lead to surprisingly thoughtful and unique gifts despite the low budget.

Regifting Party

Turn unwanted gifts into a fun exchange:

1. Ask everyone to bring a nice but unused gift they’ve received in the past.
2. Wrap the gifts without labels.
3. Use a White Elephant style exchange.
4. Encourage honesty about the gift’s origin to add humor to the exchange.

This idea gives new life to unused items and can lead to funny stories about past gifts.

Charity Donation Exchange

Focus on giving back during the holiday season:

1. Set a budget for charitable donations (e.g., $25-$50).
2. Each family member chooses a charity they want to support.
3. Use a Secret Santa format to assign gift recipients.
4. Make a donation in the recipient’s name to their chosen charity.
5. During the exchange, each person explains why they chose their charity.

This exchange promotes the spirit of giving and raises awareness about various causes.

Age-Specific Gift Exchange Ideas

Kids-Only Exchange

Create a special exchange just for the younger family members:

1. Set an age limit (e.g., 12 and under) for participation.
2. Establish a reasonable budget for kids’ gifts.
3. Use a simple name-drawing method or play an age-appropriate gift exchange game.
4. Consider having adults contribute to a pool of gifts for the kids to choose from.

This allows children to participate in gift-giving without the pressure of buying for adults.

Teen Gift Swap

Address the unique interests of teenagers:

1. Create a separate exchange for family members aged 13-19.
2. Set a budget that teens can manage (e.g., $20-$30).
3. Encourage gifts that align with teen interests like technology accessories, trendy items, or gift cards.
4. Use a White Elephant format to add excitement.

This allows teens to exchange gifts they’re more likely to appreciate and use.

Grandparents’ Choice

Honor the older generation with a special exchange:

1. Ask grandparents to choose small, meaningful items to give to grandchildren.
2. These could be family heirlooms, handmade items, or gifts with sentimental value.
3. Grandchildren draw names to determine which grandparent’s gift they receive.
4. During the exchange, grandparents can share stories about the gifts’ significance.

This exchange helps pass down family history and create connections between generations.

Practical Gift Exchange Ideas

Pantry Staples Swap

Exchange useful kitchen and household items:

1. Set a budget for pantry staples or household essentials.
2. Each person brings a basket or bag filled with practical items like spices, baking supplies, or cleaning products.
3. Use a White Elephant style exchange.
4. Encourage participants to include some specialty or gourmet items for added interest.

This exchange provides items families can actually use while introducing them to new products.

Recipe in a Jar

Combine gifting with sharing family recipes:

1. Each person prepares the dry ingredients for their favorite recipe in a jar.
2. Attach the full recipe and cooking instructions to the jar.
3. Wrap the jars and exchange using any preferred method.
4. During the exchange, each person can explain why they chose their recipe.

This idea shares family culinary traditions and provides a fun cooking project for the recipient.

Green Thumb Exchange

Perfect for gardening enthusiasts:

1. Set a budget for gardening-related gifts.
2. Ideas can include seeds, small plants, gardening tools, or decorative pots.
3. Use a Secret Santa format to assign recipients.
4. Encourage including care instructions or gardening tips with the gift.

This exchange is great for spring or summer family gatherings and promotes a shared hobby.

Virtual Gift Exchange Ideas

Online White Elephant

Adapt the classic game for remote family members:

1. Use a virtual White Elephant tool or video conferencing platform.
2. Set a budget and have participants ship gifts to a central location or directly to recipients.
3. Open gifts on camera during a video call.
4. Follow standard White Elephant rules for stealing and selecting gifts.

This allows families to maintain traditions even when they can’t be together physically.

Digital Gift Card Exchange

Keep it simple with online gift cards:

1. Set a budget for digital gift cards.
2. Use a Secret Santa format to assign recipients.
3. Purchase and send digital gift cards via email.
4. During a video call, recipients can share what they plan to buy with their gift card.

This option eliminates shipping concerns and allows for last-minute participation.

Virtual Game Night

Combine gift-giving with online gaming:

1. Choose an online multiplayer game that the whole family can enjoy.
2. Set a budget for digital gifts related to the game (e.g., in-game currency, character skins).
3. Play the game together and incorporate gift-giving into the gameplay.
4. Winners of mini-games or challenges can earn additional digital gifts.

This idea creates a fun, interactive experience that combines entertainment with gift-giving.

Christmas in Netherlands